Collections

Let customers speak for us

from 93 reviews

Its awesome., shipping was fast, packaging is just enough. It looks brand new so its not repurposed gloves?

Jerome
Black Finger Glove Purse - Rawlings White Script on Red
Perfect!

Bought it for my daughter. She loves it, as you can see. Very good quality. Thank you!
Tried to upload video but it wouldn’t let me.

John
Whenitwasagame baseballglovewallets.com

I absolutely love it

Michelle
Finger Glove Purse - Rawlings White R on Red

Authentic

Antoinette
Vida Blue Wallet With ID Holder

Well built and feels great! Lots of compliments

chris
Short Bottle Coozie - Limited Edition Brown and Tan Checkered

My guys will love them

kimberly b.
Short Black Diamond Coozie - Chicago Cubs C
Excellent quality

I was extremely skeptical when purchasing this for my wife. It surpassed my expectations. Details are great and it’s a very unique piece for her collection

Stephen J.
Glove Finger Purse - Atlanta Braves A

Love

Terie
Glove Finger Purse - Houston Astros

Beautiful

Kim
Finger Glove Purse - Rawlings Red R On Gold
Love it

So cute and well made. I changed out the strap to match my so sons team but have been asked by a bunch of moms where it came from :)

Courtney C.
Finger Glove Purse - Blank No Patch
Absolutely in love!

I ordered it and was delivered very quickly! It's very cute and definitely a one of a kind! I highly recommend!!

Raemarie M.
Glove Fingers Cubs Purse
Perfect

The size and style are so cute!!

Casey M.
Finger Glove Purse - Blank No Patch

I love it ! It is awesome

Kathy
Finger Glove Wristlet - Chicago Cubs C
Awesome & creative

Very nice coozie, looks just like the picture! Great craftsmanship! My husband absolutely loves it!

Hailey H.
Pocket Coozie - St Louis Cardinals Bird

Amazing quality fast shipping far exceeded my expectations too. Thank you for this great idea for a gift

Rich
Pocket Coozie - Mixed Shades

Find items for your team!

WhenItWasAGame.Org

Where old baseball gloves get a new life! We have been doing this longer than anyone (check the reviews!) We take old baseball gloves and turn them into a variety of styled wallets. We also use baseball glove leather to make coozies and purses. We are happy to customize orders with bespoke patch designs and wallets custom made from your own gloves. Please don't hesitate to contact us with any questions or inquiries!

Featured products

1 25
View all